Your new favorite bakery in Webster
Breads, pastries, cookies and cakes, all made from scratch.
Sweet Shenanigans is a small from-scratch bakery in the heart of the village. We fill the case fresh every morning with artisan breads, flaky pastries, cookies, bars and cheesecakes. Stop in and find your new favorite.
Fresh from the oven, every day
A little bit of everything, made by hand in small batches. Here is what fills the case day to day, with seasonal specials on top of it.
Breads & Pastries
Sandwich loaves, focaccia and salty bread, plus danishes, turnovers, bear claws, coffeecake and cinnamon rolls.
See the list
Cookies & Bars
A dozen cookie flavors, from chocolate chip to Russian tea, plus lemon bars, brownies and éclairs.
See the list
Cakes & Cheesecakes ask in store
New York cheesecakes, cupcakes and decorated cakes. For something custom, just talk to us in the shop.
See the list
A case worth stopping for
Lemon bars, brownies and raspberry almond tarts. Assorted mini New York cheesecakes. Boston cream cookies, éclairs, cupcakes and a dozen kinds of cookie. It is all baked here, in small batches, and it sells the way fresh things do.
Come early for the best pick of the day.
Hi, we are Brittany & Kyle
Brittany has been baking in some way or another for eighteen years. It started with friends in high school, turned into a job at the bakery inside Turning Stone Casino & Resort, and then close to eight years as a pastry chef at a fine-dining restaurant in the Finger Lakes.
A shop of our own was always the goal. We looked all over for the right place, and then one day it just happened.
“We kind of just fell into it. I happened to be looking at the right place, at the right time, on the right day.”
That place is right here on East Main Street in the Village of Webster. Everything we make is from scratch and baked fresh. We would love for you to come say hello.
Wholesale & bulk baking
We have supplied local spots with fresh baked goods for years. If you run a cafe, restaurant or shop and want quality baked goods made nearby, let us talk.